Skip to content

Collector guide · 11 min

Getting a Persian rug appraised: what an appraiser checks

Editorial team · updated 2026-09-29

Carpet with Repeating Tree Design, probably late 17th–early 18th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), wool (pile); asymmetrically knotted pile
Related craft illustration; not a demonstration of this guide’s process or evidence of a named place.Carpet with Repeating Tree Design, probably late 17th–early 18th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), wool (pile); asymmetrically knotted pile

probably late 17th–early 18th century · accession 14.40.710 · The Metropolitan Museum of Art · CC0 (Met Open Access) · Photo source ↗

At a glance
Type
Collector guide
Reading
11 min
Chapters
10
Photos
6

A Persian rug appraisal records type, origin, age, materials, condition and a value for a stated purpose such as insurance or sale.

The short answer

A rug appraiser examines the rug, identifies its type and origin, estimates its age, checks materials and condition, and gives a value for a specific purpose — insurance, sale, estate or donation. Different purposes can give different values.

What the appraiser checks

  • Knot type and density on the back
  • Foundation and pile fibres
  • Dyes and colour quality
  • Design and origin
  • Age signs
  • Wear, repairs, moth damage, stains, colour run

Choosing an appraiser

Choose someone independent who does not offer to buy the rug. Ask about their rug experience and professional memberships, and whether they give a written report.

What to bring

Any receipts, history and photos. For large rugs, ask about home visits or photo-based preliminary opinions.

Cost

Fees vary by region and purpose; ask in advance. A fee based on a percentage of value is a conflict of interest.

Choosing an appraiser

Choose an independent appraiser who does not offer to buy the rug, ideally one with recognised credentials. Ask what kind of value is being estimated: insurance, resale or donation.

Start with
Purpose, intended users and valuation date
Report
Object identification, evidence, assumptions and method
Avoid
An unexplained number or an undisclosed buying interest

Commission the right kind of opinion

Ask who will use the report and for what decision: insurance, an estate, a proposed sale or another purpose. The value definition, relevant market and effective date must be agreed before work begins. Requirements for tax or legal use depend on jurisdiction.

An insurance replacement assessment is not a prediction of auction proceeds. A dealer’s purchase offer is not the same service as an independent appraisal. A preliminary photo opinion should state what the appraiser has not examined.

Build an inspectable object record

Provide dimensions, accessible construction views, purchase records, previous reports and a dated condition history. Identify inscriptions, labels and repairs without assuming they prove the attribution. Ask how the examination will be conducted for a large or fragile carpet.

A report should distinguish observed features from reported history and specialist interpretation. Uncertain dyes, age, manufacture and restoration should remain qualified. Do not clean or repair the rug merely to prepare for appraisal without discussing whether treatment is warranted.

  • Inventory identifier and current photographs
  • Dimensions and construction observations
  • Condition and known treatments
  • Documents with dates and named sources

Ask how comparable evidence was selected

Comparable sales must be relevant to the stated value basis and date. Size, attribution, condition, market location and the treatment of fees can explain why apparently similar results differ. A public asking price records an offer, not necessarily a completed transaction.

Ask the appraiser to explain the limitations of the available evidence. A museum photograph documents a collection object, not a comparable sale. The illustrations on this page carry no price or appraisal implication.

Review independence and the finished report

Ask about relevant rug experience, professional standards, conflicts of interest, fee basis and any reliance on other specialists. Membership or certification should be checked, but it does not remove the need for relevant expertise and a clear scope.

Read the effective date, value definition, intended use, assumptions and restrictions. Discuss material errors and retain the signed report with photographs. Updating an appraisal is a separate decision; neither a universal review interval nor automatic annual appreciation is appropriate.

Related photographs and screened examples

Vase Carpet, late 16th–early 17th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), silk (weft), wool (weft and pile); asymmetrically knotted pile
Vase Carpet, late 16th–early 17th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), silk (weft), wool (weft and pile); asymmetrically knotted pilelate 16th–early 17th century · accession 43.121.2The Metropolitan Museum of Art · CC0 (Met Open Access) · Image source ↗
"Floral and Cloudband" Carpet, 17th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), wool (pile); asymmetrically knotted pile
"Floral and Cloudband" Carpet, 17th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), wool (pile); asymmetrically knotted pile17th century · accession 53.214The Metropolitan Museum of Art · CC0 (Met Open Access) · Image source ↗
Garden Carpet, second half 18th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), wool (pile); symmetrically knotted pile
Garden Carpet, second half 18th century; Iran. Cotton (warp and weft), wool (pile); symmetrically knotted pilesecond half 18th century · accession 22.100.128The Metropolitan Museum of Art · CC0 (Met Open Access) · Image source ↗
Silk Animal Carpet, second half 16th century; Iran. Silk (warp, weft, and pile); asymmetrically knotted pile
Silk Animal Carpet, second half 16th century; Iran. Silk (warp, weft, and pile); asymmetrically knotted pilesecond half 16th century · accession 14.40.721The Metropolitan Museum of Art · CC0 (Met Open Access) · Image source ↗
Photograph from Wikimedia Commons
Date unverifiedAuthor unconfirmed; Commons attributes Fabienkhan · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Image source ↗

Representative photographs only. Marketplace examples rely on seller descriptions; CraftPersia has not independently authenticated their maker, origin, or rights status. Follow each source link for the listing context.

What to check in an appraisal
Record or observationWhat to doWhat it cannot establish
Purpose and dateConfirm intended use and effective dateA value valid for every purpose
IdentificationSeparate observations from attributionCertain age from appearance
ComparablesReview relevance and fee treatmentA transferable price from a similar image
Conflict and feeRequest written disclosure and fee basisIndependence from a free estimate

References and further reading

  1. [1] Encyclopaedia Iranica — Carpets: overview and bibliography ↗Historical and technical context; not a valuation or authentication of the photographed objects.
  2. [2] The George Washington University Museum and The Textile Museum ↗Collection and textile-study resources; a photograph cannot substitute for structural examination.
  3. [3] American Society of Appraisers — Professional appraisal resources ↗Check applicable professional and jurisdictional requirements for the intended use.

These sources provide context, not authentication or provenance for an individual object. Editorial interpretations remain under review.